Honda Freed | Toyota Kijang Innova | Nissan Grand Livina
Specification Comparison of Honda Freed | Toyota Kijang Innova | Nissan Grand Livina
By Ali Budiman
Honda Freed Review
By June 29, 2009, PT. Honda Prospect Motors release Honda Freed to Indonesia auto market. Priced at Rp. 237 Million for Standard type and Rp. 257 Million for highest variants (RS Type). Its makes Honda Freed head to head with Toyota Kijang Innova and Nissan Grand Livina. Even the engine capacity of Honda Freed is only 1.5 liter, same capacity with Toyota Avanza 1.5 and Nissan Grand Livina 1.5, its fair if we compare Honda Freed with Toyota Kijang Innova 2.0 AT G-type & V-type (Captain Seat), also with Nissan Grand Livina 1.8L AT Ultimate.
Below is Specification Comparison of Honda Freed, Toyota Kijang Innova, and Nissan Grand Livina:
|
Honda Freed 1.5AT |
Toyota Kijang Innova 2.0 AT G/V Captain Seat |
Nissan Grand Livina 1.8 AT Ultimate |
| Price | ||
|
S type = Rp. 237 Mills RS type = Rp. 257 Mills |
G -AT = Rp. 241.60 Mills V-AT = Rp. 272.75 Mills |
Rp. 241.5 Mills
|
| Engine Specification | ||
|
1,497 cc i-VTEC 16V |
1,998 cc VVT-i 16V |
1,798 cc CVTC 16V |
| Max power (PS/rpm) | ||
|
118 / 6,600 |
136 / 5,600 |
126 / 5,200 |
| Max Torque (Kgm/rpm) | ||
|
14.9 / 4,800 |
18.6 / 4000 |
17.7 / 4,800 |
| Suspension | ||
|
Front : McPherson Strut with Stabilizer |
Double Wishbone with Coil Spring and Stabilizer |
McPherson strut with stabilizer |
|
Rear : H-Shape Torsion Beam |
4 Link with Coil Spring and Lateral Rod |
Torsion beam with stabilizer |
| Dimension | ||
| Length X Width X Height (mm) | ||
|
4215 x 1700 x 1735 |
4555 x 1770 x 1745 |
4420 x 1690 x 1595 |
| Wheelbase (mm) | ||
|
2740 |
2750 |
2600 |
| Minimum Turning radius | ||
|
5.2 meter |
5.4 m |
5.3 m |
| Fuel Tank Capacity | ||
|
42 liter |
65 liter |
52.4 liter |
| Ground Clearance | ||
|
165 mm |
200 mm |
185 mm |
| Tyre & Wheel | ||
|
185/65 R15 Alloy |
205/65 R15 Alloy |
185/65 R15 Alloy |
| Safety Features | ||
| Brake System | ||
|
ABS+EBD+BA |
ABS+EBD (V type) |
ABS+EBD+BA |
| SRS Airbag | ||
|
Dual Airbag (RS Type) Neck Shock Mitigation Head Rest |
Dual Airbag (V type) |
Drivers only |
| Safety Belt | ||
|
1st, 2nd, 3rd row |
1st, 2nd, 3rd row |
1st & 2nd row |
| Pretensioner Belt With Double Load Limiter | ||
|
RS Type |
- |
- |
| Key & Alarm System | ||
|
Wave Key, Keyless Entry, Immobilizer |
Integrated Key with Alarm, Parking Sensor |
Keyless Entry, Anti Theft, Parking Sensor |
| Exterior |
| Door Mirror | ||
|
Electric Body Color |
Electric Body Color (G) /Chrome (V) |
Electric Body Color with Turning Lamp |
| Rear Passenger Door | ||
|
Manual Sliding (S) Automatic Sliding (RS) |
Konvensional |
Konvensional |
| Interior |
| Seat Configuration | ||
|
King & Queen Seat, 2+2+3, Fabric |
Captain Seat, 2+2+3, Fabric |
2+3+2, Leather Seat |
| Audio | ||
|
Double Din AM/FM CD MP3/WMA/WAV + USB + AUX input + i-POD ready |
2Din – CD, MP3, WMA V-type : 6CD with Steering switch |
6CD inDash, MP3, WMA
|
| Supporting | ||
| Warranty | ||
|
3 years or 100,000 km |
3 years or 100,000 km |
3 years or 100,000 km |
| Emergency Assistance | ||
|
24 Hours Road Assistance |
24 Hours Road Assistance |
24 Hours Road Assistance |
So, which MPV you want to buy, if you have buying budget about Rp. 200 Mills up to 300 Mills? Honda Freed, Toyota Kijang Innova or Nissan Grand Livina?
Kalau boleh tau, berat masing2 kendaraan berapa ? karena itu sangat berpengaruh dengan tenaga dan bahan bakar. kalau tiap hari bawa beban berat harus jadi pertimbangan.
Curb Weight :
Toyota Kijang Innova 2.0 G-Type AT = 1,555 kg (MT : 1,530 kg)
Nissan Grand Livina 1.8 Ultimate AT = 1,250 kg (MT : 1,225 kg)
Honda Freed = 1,280 kg
How about fuel consumption?
And How about Proton Exora? Ever make comparison?
Honda state the fuel consumption of Freed is almost same with Jazz/City. But in our opinion Freed is poor (than Jazz and City) since the curb weight is hug.
Innova fuel consumption about 1 liter for 10km. Grand Livina more economical, about 1:12. (its our opinion)
Exora? You can see http://indonesia-cars.com/532/proton-exora-specification/
The number of fuel consumption will be different in various road/traffic condition and depend on driver habits.
i made comparison between some mpvs .. here guys http://i29.tinypic.com/357g6j8.jpg
panjang dalam kabin yang paling panjang mana antara innova livina dan freed
yang memiliki ruang bagasi paliing luas yang mana?
Karena saya punya GL, 1.8 ultimate, 6speed. Dari perbandingan yg ada, saya tetap memilih GL. Karena FC benar bisa 1liter :10-12km. Akselerasi& power mesin lebih mantap. Bagasi luas & mutifungsi, bisa jadi tempat tidur anak2. Anak2 saya ber-3, bandung-jakarta, tidur pulas mulai berangkat sampai garasi rumah. THE BEST FOR PRICES&PERFOMANCE. Tapi memang merk & model memiliki kelebihan masing-masing. Jadi semua terkembali kepada pilihan pribadi masing2. Salam. Drive safe
klo baris ketiga ditekuk maka luas bagasi freed sama denagn innova, tetapi jika ditutup, sepertinya freed kalah sedikit…tapi teman saya pernah mencoba memasukan tas golf yang besar itu ke freed dan muat, sedangkan di tauh di belakang innova gak muat
heheheh
jadi freed still the best
On the exterior, Honda Freed is the most handsome, and I really like the auto-sliding door for RS type, so cool!
Just share,,, saya baru terima GL 8 Dec\\\’09
Nissan GL 1.8XV M/T, very powerfull, speed di toll, cikampek / kanci 180-190 enteng dan bodi anteng tidak limbung penumpang 3 dewasa 3 anak-anak. Tanjakan lewat lereng gunung slamet (dari semua mobil MPV yang pernah saya pakai)lewat semua wow,,,,,, . GL memang MPV performance Sedan…BBM 1/10km… puasssssss
Untuk safety Freed jelas lebih unggul.
Untuk safety Freed jelas lebih unggul. Toyota Innova tidak safe.
Bagaimana dengan bahan bakar GL? Apa harus pertamax? Bgm dgn premium? Apa berpengaruh pada performance (akselerasi etc..). Mhn pencerahannya?